Manhattan Pizza

305 Matthews Drive, Holly Springs, NC 27540, USA

About Manhattan Pizza

4.7 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Jared Cook
    July 08, 2022

    Delicious pizza with a great selection of specialty pizzas! Fast service and it looks like they have a ice cream parlor too! We'll be coming back for sure!

    Ned Shipley
    October 18, 2022

    Got my pizza and garlic knots delivered 30 minutes ago. The knots, weren't knots, they just balls of bread, that came without a side sauce. And The pizza was ok. My MAJOR issue was that the pepperoni on the pizza was not cooked on the pizza. It was put in a fryer then added to my pizza after the fact. As someone who has worked in a pizza shop for years this "trick" other than looking and tasting like it was fried. This way of cooking the pepperoni also tells on its self as the pepperoni is super greasy but there is no pepperoni greasy on the pizza. Why would there be. It was fried let cool in the basket then put on the pizza after it came out. This is also the reason that not 1 pepperoni stuck to my pizza. Because they were cooked separately. Pretty disappointing to get a below average pizza, with obviously fried pepperoni, that cost me almost $30 on my first time ordering from your place. More than likely won't be going back.

    Garrett Heflin
    August 12, 2022

    Today was our first time trying this place. The pizza was not terrible….BUT I ordered a truffle porcini that did not have any truffle paste on it, and a mac and cheese pizza that literally had three little pieces of mac and cheese on each slice (large pizza) - was FAR from the picture loaded with mac and cheese like it was an actual topping. The truffle paste kind of makes the porcini pizza so that was just eh. The mac and cheese pizza had great flavor if you want a basil cheese pizza. Unfortunately I wanted it because I love mac and cheese and paid for the specialty pizza. Overall, a very expensive ($80) trial that wasn’t worth it. If I ever go back in the future I will plan to eat there so I can make sure I get the toppings I paid for before I leave 🙄.

    Phil Silverman
    March 24, 2022

    I've ordered from here since this place first opened during COVID and never had an issue. Lately however, the quality has gone down significantly. Second time I've received my pizza not cut. Also, the wings have shrunk quite a bit.

    Kelley Harrell
    August 09, 2022

    They offer gluten-free crusts, though I don't know how they handle their CC process. On that note I've not had any illness, and still approach with concern. Their pizzas are very good. Their toppings seem more fresh and flavorful than other places. However, they don't exactly distribute them evenly. We ordered four pizzas, each with full coverage toppings. All of them had mounds of toppings in various places, so that you didn't get a bite of everything all-at-once on any of them. I should have taken photos. I don't know why they allow you to divide pizzas by what toppings you want where if they aren't going to follow the instruction.

    Manhattan Pizza

    Our Address

    305 Matthews Drive, Holly Springs, NC 27540, USA

    Ad 2

    Ads Title

    Interested in highlighting a business on this site?

    Find out how by clicking the Claim My Listing button!